[[Category:Wikipedia Mediation Cabal closed cases|David Hicks]][[Category:Wikipedia Mediation Cabal maintenance|David Hicks]]

SmithBlue, Prester John and Skyring

Prester John edited 3 times to include material that was not verifiable in the references supplied. Prester John defended these edits as being allowed by WP:WEIGHT and promoted a view of the removals of his edits as "disruptive behaviour". Skyring promoted a view of the removal of Prester John's edits as "edit warring".

I would like a consensus view to form on how Prester John's edits relate to WP policies, and a consensus to form on the promotion of the view, by Skyring and Prester John, that WP:WEIGHT was more important that WP:OR and WP:BLP in this matter.