User:Fastfoodfanatic/Race and transportation planning in the United States
Racial demographics of areas have often impacted transportation planning in the United States. Even when there is no explicit intent of racism, there are often still racial disparities in various transport-related statistics, including pedestrian fatalities.
Background
Racism has been an ongoing issue in the United States, reflected in numerous aspects of American life and culture.
In the Southern United States, Jim Crow laws were in effect from the late 19th century to the mid-20th century. These laws required virtually all aspects of Southern life, including public transit vehicles, to be segregated by race. However, less overt segregation also happened in other parts of the country.
After World War II and through the Civil Rights Movement, white middle-class residents of many urban areas (both within and outside the South) moved to rapidly-developing suburbs in large numbers, a phenomenon known as white flight. Catalysts for this population shift included mandated desegregation of public facilities such as public schools (later including practices such as busing) as well as the Interstate Highway System, redlining, exclusionary covenants, and mortgage discrimination making it easier for whites to move to suburbs, while black populations and other communities of color could not, even when they could afford it.
This wave of suburbs was designed around the car, and were conceived as racially exclusive communities. (Even today, suburbs tend to be whiter than the cities they surround.) As a result of suburbanization and rising automobile use, public transit ridership massively dropped in cities across the US post-World War II, continuing a general downward trend since the 1920s.
Today, while driving remains by far the most popular mode of transportation nationwide among all US racial groups, people of color generally use transit, walk, and cycle at higher rates than whites in many US cities and metropolitan areas, where usage of non-car travel modes is heavier, and make up a larger share of transit ridership nationwide.[1]
Road design and safety
After World War II, highways were built and expanded nationwide as part of the Interstate Highway System. As mentioned above, highways were a driver of white flight to suburbs. Additionally, highways were often built straight through neighborhoods populated primarily by African Americans (or other communities of color such as Asian Americans[2]), requiring residents' homes to be demolished by eminent domain. In many cases, even when a white neighborhood or other alignment (such as an old railroad track) would be more direct, the planners still would build through the non-white neighborhood due to lower land values and lack of political power to oppose construction, both symptoms of racial discrimination.[3] Alternatively, some alignments were chosen to physically separate white neighborhoods with neighborhoods populated primarily by people of color.[4] In some cases, highway revolts were started, to protest said construction.
Fatal pedestrian accidents, already a bigger issue in the US compared to many other developed countries[5] and continuing an upward trend as of 2023-2024,[6][7] disproportionately impact people of color (specifically African Americans, Hispanic Americans, and American Indian and Alaska Native populations).[8] Additionally, the enforcement of jaywalking laws by police has at times had racial disparities,[9][10][11] leading some US cities and states, such as New York City[10] and California,[11] to decriminalize jaywalking in the 2020s.
Public transit design, funding, and implementation
Public transit in the United States, especially local buses, and to a lesser extent passenger rail, have a huge stigma associated with them, specifically that they are mainly used by poorer people, especially racial minorities, who often have no other way of getting around. This stigma creates obstacles for funding, as well as implementation, such as local opposition to buses running to richer areas and malls on the grounds that it would bring crime.[12][13][14]
On the other hand, many forms of public transit (primarily heavy or light rail, streetcars, bus rapid transit and park-and-ride buses), in addition to walkability and bike lane projects, have been accused of gentrification at the expense of people of color,[12] or been designed in a manner that reinforces racial disparities.
Examples
Racial opposition to transit funding or implementation
- In Atlanta, it is often argued that racial politics play a role in the operation and future service planning for MARTA, the city's transit authority. Opponents of Georgia's transportation policies have alleged a race-based two-tiered system, where billions are spent by the state on highway expansion to aid the automobile commutes of mostly White residents of the suburbs and rural areas (like GRIP), while service cuts at MARTA have hurt mostly African Americans in low-income areas where residents cannot afford automobile ownership.[15] Proponents contest that a portion of state funding for highways comes from the gasoline tax, a user fee analogous to the fare MARTA riders pay. Supporters of MARTA have alleged that the lack of participation by other metro Atlanta counties is rooted in racism and classism.[15][16] In 1987, David Chesnut, then chairman of MARTA, stated, "The development of a regional transit system in the Atlanta area is being held hostage to race, and I think it's high time we admitted it and talked about it."[17] As part of its Title VI plan, MARTA data revealed that 75 percent of MARTA riders were Black in 2015.[18] MARTA is often given the racially charged backronym "Moving Africans Rapidly Through Atlanta", referring to its mostly African American ridership, particularly outside of rush hours.[19][20] Suburban counties' opposition to MARTA expansion is often due to fears of it causing increased crime, as well as the cost of expansion and perceived lack of need for the service.
- In the 1990s in Buffalo, New York, Walden Galleria management opposed a bus from the majority Black inner city — and not those from majority white suburbs and even Canada — from stopping on the mall grounds. As a result, bus riders from the inner city getting off the bus had to cross seven lanes of traffic without a crosswalk to reach the mall. This led to the death of a 17-year-old Black teenager, Cynthia N. Wiggins, who was crossing the street from the bus stop to her job when she was hit by a dump truck, after which the mall was accused of racism. In settling a wrongful death claim against Walden Galleria and NFTA Metro and to prevent a boycott of the mall, the bus stop was soon moved to a point inside the mall, where it remains today.[21][22][23][24][25]
- Washington Metro's College Park station, on the Green Line, was built further from the University of Maryland than planned due to opposition from university leaders. At the time, Washington D.C. was overwhelmingly Black, and the university was overwhelmingly white. In 2017, former Maryland Governor and Prince George's County Executive Parris Glendening admitted the university's decision to have the Metro station as far away from campus as possible, or 1.6 miles (2.6 km), requiring students to take a student-operated shuttle bus to access the campus, was a "disaster" and racially biased. He claims that it was primarily due to administrators and community residents saying they did not want crime or undesirable people coming to campus on the Green Line from the poorer neighborhoods of Washington.[26][27]
Racially biased effects of transit design (including gentrification)
- Although Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) in the San Francisco Bay Area was built to race-neutral specifications, the system's design was alleged by Robert O. Self’s book American Babylon: Race and the Struggle for Postwar Oakland to be focused on serving white suburban commuters. A notable example of design that has been considered to have racially biased effects is the gap of 2.7 miles (4.3 km) between Fruitvale and Lake Merritt stations, the longest distance between any two city stations in the system. Here, trains run non-stop through the racially diverse urban neighborhood of San Antonio, Oakland.[12][28] However, in modern times, Blacks and Latinos are overrepresented in its ridership, with whites and Asians underrepresented.[29]
Policing
Policing on many city transit systems, including New York City Transit, is often unfairly biased towards people of color, particularly Blacks and Latinos.
Racial representation in leadership
Minorities are regularly underrepresented in public transit leadership, despite being overrepresented (in most cases) in lower-level staff and system ridership.[30]
Links to other aspects of policy
See also
- Environmental racism
- Anti-urbanism
- Societal effects of cars#United States
- Car dependency
- Motonormativity
References
- ^ Clark, Hugh M. (January 2017). "Who Rides Public Transportation" (PDF). American Public Transportation Association. Retrieved 13 September 2025.
- ^ "Seattle Chinatown Historic District (U.S. National Park Service)". www.nps.gov. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ Sullivan, Andy. "U.S. freeways flattened Black neighborhoods nationwide". Reuters. Thomson Reuters. Retrieved October 20, 2022.
- ^ Kruse, Kevin M. (August 14, 2019). "How Segregation Caused Your Traffic Jam". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Archived from the original on November 17, 2023. Retrieved November 16, 2023.
- ^ Staff, Vox (2022-12-06). "A crisis on America's roads". Vox. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ Kim, Juliana (2023-06-26). "U.S. pedestrian deaths reach a 40-year high". NPR. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ "Early 2024 U.S. Pedestrian Fatalities Up 48% From a Decade Ago | Governors Highway Safety Association". www.ghsa.org. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ Panhorst, Juliana; Ryan, Alyssa (13 January 2025). "Pedestrian Fatalities and Their Demographic Disparities in the US". Findings. doi:10.32866/001c.127604. Retrieved 11 April 2025.
- ^ Sanders, Topher; Rabinowitz, Kate; Conarck, Benjamin (2017-11-16). "Walking While Black". ProPublica. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ a b Wise, Alana (2024-10-30). "Enforcement was considered discriminatory. Now New Yorkers can jaywalk legally". NPR. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ a b Chow, Vivian (2022-10-01). "New law allows Californians to legally jaywalk". KTLA. Retrieved 2022-10-01.
- ^ a b c Spieler, Christof. "Racism has shaped public transit, and it's riddled with inequities". Kinder Institute for Urban Research - Rice University. Retrieved October 20, 2022.
- ^ Hess, Amanda. "Race, Class, and the Stigma of Riding the Bus in America". The Atlantic. The Atlantic. Retrieved October 20, 2022.
- ^ Ramey, Corinne. "America's Unfair Rules of the Road". Slate. The Slate Group. Retrieved October 20, 2022.
- ^ a b Cite error: The named reference
cloafwas invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ "Atlanta weighing transit expansion". The New York Times. August 13, 1989. Retrieved February 24, 2008.
- ^ Schmidt, William (July 22, 1987). "Racial roadblock seen in Atlanta transit system". The New York Times. Retrieved February 27, 2008.
- ^ "Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority Title VI Program Update June 2016 - 2019" (PDF). Itsmarta.com. Retrieved 26 March 2019.
- ^ McCosh, John (February 11, 2001). "MARTA calls on marketers for image aid; Can soft drinks fill empty seats?". The Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
- ^ Torres, Angel O.; Bullard, Robert D.; Johnson, Glenn D. (2004). Highway robbery: transportation racism & new routes to equity. Boston: South End Press. p. 53. ISBN 0-89608-704-2.
- ^ Nieves, Evelyn (1996-12-19). "The Cynthia Wiggins case". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-05-17.
- ^ "Buffalo, NY, Family Settles For $2.55 Mil. In Suit Charging Woman's Death Was Due To Racism At Mall (Jet)". Jet. 1999. Retrieved 2008-05-17.
- ^ "Johnnie L. Cochran Jr. takes case of black teen killed by dump truck on her way to mall". Jet. 1996. Retrieved 2008-05-18.
- ^ "Bed Bath & Beyond opens first area store in Galleria". The Buffalo News. 1997-05-01. Retrieved 2007-10-01.
- ^ "Bonwit Teller store closing". The Buffalo News. 1996-10-18. Retrieved 2007-10-01.
- ^ "Off-Campus Metro Stop in College Park a 'Disaster': Glendening". Maryland Matters. November 1, 2017. Archived from the original on November 17, 2017. Retrieved November 16, 2017.
- ^ Carter-Conneen, Mike. "Former Maryland Governor: College Park UMD Metro location 'a huge mistake'". WJLA. Archived from the original on November 17, 2017. Retrieved November 16, 2017.
- ^ Fermoso, Jose (2024-07-18). "BART skips over this Oakland neighborhood. Residents are campaigning for a station". The Oaklandside. Retrieved 2025-09-13.
- ^ https://www.bart.gov/sites/default/files/docs/CS2020_Report_Issued032221.pdf [bare URL PDF]
- ^ Rennert, Lindiwe; Fung, Lauren; Harvey, Donovan (31 July 2024). "Transit Agency Leaders Rarely Reflect the Race and Gender Diversity of the Populations They Serve". Urban Institute. Retrieved 11 April 2025.