Zmiana (lit. 'Change') is an unregistered[15] left-wing[9] political party in Poland. The party was founded on 21 February 2015 by Mateusz Piskorski, a former vice-president and spokesman of Self-Defence of the Republic of Poland.[2] The party calls for rapprochement between Poland and Russia, and supports Russian in the Russo-Ukrainian War.[16] In 2016, Piskorski was arrested on charges of espionage for Russia, Iraq and China.[17] Piskorski was later released in 2019 on bail.[18] Zmiana calls for Polish exit from NATO,[19] abolition of capitalism, [21] and establishment of economy based on socialist and communist ideals.[2][5][22] Zmiana officially has never been registered as a political party because it was refused a registration by a court.[3] It is commonly accused of being "Russian fifth column" by Polish right-leaning politicians and the press.[2]
History
Zmiana was founded in February 2015[23] by Mateusz Piskorski, a geopolitical analyst and former parliamentarian of the far-left populist party Self-Defence of the Republic of Poland.[18] Piskorski came in contact with Russian philosopher Aleksander Dugin in 2004 during his observatory mission to the 2004 Belarusian parliamentary election. Piskorski then went on to participate in the 2005 Transnistrian parliamentary election as an international observer; after returning to Poland, he proclaimed that he would work towards a Polish recognition of Transnistria.[24]
In the face of electoral gridlock in 2006, Samoobrona decided to enter a coalition with right-wing parties Law and Justice and League of Polish Families.[17] This was done despite limited political overlap - Samoobrona was described a left-wing, nationalist and religious conservative.[24] At that time, Piskorski became the spokesman of Samoobrona. The coalition collapsed, and the leader of Samoobrona, Andrzej Lepper, died in "strange and unexplained circumstances", with some arguing that Lepper's death was related with the revenge of Law and Justice.[17]
After Lepper's death, Piskorski became the vice-president of Samoobrona. In June 2013, he went to Syria to support Bashar al-Assad.[25] In response to the Annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation, Piskorski became an observer in the 2014 Crimean status referendum,[26] deeming it fair and justifying Russian actions as "a natural reaction to a situation in which country’s compatriots are threatened by Ukrainian nationalists".[27]
In 2007, Piskorski also founded the European Center for Geopolitical Analysis (ECAG), which became the think tank of Zmiana. ECAG promotes Eurasianist ideology that advocates for a Eurasian society with Russia at its center. ECAG members were frequently invited to regions such as Crimea, Abkhazia, Transnistria, Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as countries such as Belarus, Libya and Syria, as electoral observers. In 2012, Piskorski travelled to Moscow and establishment more political links there.[28]
Zmiana was founded on 21 February 2015 by factions of communist youth organisations, former Samoobrona members, Falanga, as well as minor trade union, socialist, and anti-imperialist movements. Zmiana's founding congress also included a speech by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Donetsk People’s Republic, who attended through a video message as he was denied entry into Poland.[22] Tomasz Jankowski was elected as the party's spokesman.[2] While the leader of Falanga Bartosz Bekier was elected the vice-president of the party, Bekier and the rest of Falanga would later leave Zmiana in 2016, giving the party a more defined left-wing character.[29]
The party was invigilated by the Internal Security Agency since its foundation, as Polish state officials suspected and accused the party of being financed and controlled by Russian intelligence agencies. In April, the state-owned TV station Telewizja Polska called the party "Putin's fifth column" and refused to interview Jankowski. Other Polish media called for a boycott of the party and refusing any interviews with it, arguing that giving Zmiana a voice would destabilize Polish social order.[2]
The decision of Telewizja Polska and other media was condemned by activists of the Democratic Left Alliance, who stated: "You allow the far right to express their views in the form of RN, MW, KNP and KORWiN, and when the anti-capitalist party was formed, you denied it the right to freedom of speech. And unlike the far right, it does not promote racial or national hatred." Telewizja Polska responded to the accusations, stating that while it did interview far-right and antisemitic personas like Leszek Bubel, these were "products of our [Polish] own backyard", and alleged that Zmiana is Russian-funded and therefore "something else".[2]
In April 2015, youth activists of Zmiana protested against the unveiling of a plaque commemorating the victims of the Smoleńsk catastrophe in Grudziądz. The party also called for an official recognition of the Donetsk People's Republic and the Luhansk People's Republic. In the same year, Zmiana welcomed Night Wolves on the Polish-Belarusian border. In response to the party's actions, Polish political scientist Grzegorz Baziur called for the arrest of the party's members, writing: "In the event of a possible Russian-Polish conflict or a real threat of one, they should be interned, like many activists of the Polish Communist Workers' Party in 1919-1920, who also demanded a change in the political system of the newly reborn Second Polish Republic and its incorporation into Soviet Russia at the time."[2]
Zmiana attempted to participate in the 2015 parliamentary election, claiming it could capture up to 12% of the vote,[30] though it ultimately failed to register as a party in the country's party registry.[15]
After Piskorski was imprisoned for espionage on the behalf of Russia and China on 17 May 2016,[31] the party raised funds and managed to have him released on bail in 2019.[32] Marxists circles criticized the arrest, noting that "what is spectacular the accusation was changing from being spy of Russia to being spy of China or Iraq"; some also connected Piskorski's arrest to Lepper's death, as Piskorski was writing a book about Samoobrona and the unexplained death of its leader. Law and Justice is alleged to have been involved in Lepper's death, and it became the ruling party in the 2015 Polish parliamentary election, shortly before Piskorski's arrest.[17]
In the 2019 Polish elections for Senate, party vice-chairman Konrad Rękas ran in Senate Constituency 18 (Chełm) on the lists of Przywrócić Prawo , coming third with 7.87% of the vote (7,958 votes).[33]
When in detention, Piskorski was questioned about alleged ties to Manuel Ochsenreiter (Germany), Piotr Łuszczak (Die Linke, Germany) and Anna Eurdová (ČSSD, Czechia), as well as the United Romania Party, People's Party Our Slovakia and the Hungarian Revolutionary Movement.[31] After his release, Piskorski became a contributor to the news agency Sputnik.[6]
Ideology
Zmiana is a left-wing,[6][9][10][11][12] anti-capitalist,[6][11][20] and pro-Russian party.[1] It advocates for a withdrawal from NATO[34] and the European Union. Political observers noted that the party is influenced by Polish socialism based on the People’s Republic of Poland, as well as by Russian nationalist philosopher Aleksander Dugin.[8] The party was accused of being funded by anti-Western countries such as Russia, and Piskorski is also alleged to have had backing from Gaddafi's Libya. It also has its own think tank, the European Centre for Geopolitical Analysis.[4] The party also has its own trade union led by Piotr Kret - the Free Trade Union ‘Zmiana’ - Unity of Labour (Polish: Wolny Związek Zawodowy „Zmiana” – Jedność Pracownicza). The slogan of the party is Labour, Peace, Patriotism (Polish: Praca, Pokój, Patriotyzm), based on the slogans used by the Polish United Workers' Party - Labour, Peace, Socialism (Polish: Praca, Pokój, Socjalizm).[2]
The party has been described as 'pro-communist' - at the same time it refers to Polish patriotism and claims the tradition of the interwar Polish Socialist Party, naming Polish socialists such as Bolesław Limanowski, Ignacy Daszyński and Stefan Aleksander Okrzeja as its main ideological inspirations. Zmiana condemns Polish right-wing and anti-communist parties and movements, such as the Home Army, Freedom and Independence Association, as well as contemporary right-wing parties like Law and Justice, Confederation of Independent Poland and the Solidarity movement. It also calls for restoration of the 'good name of the Red Army, and restoration of Soviet monuments in Poland.[2] The party has also been described as socialist-patriotic; in an interview with Polish journalist Jan Herman, Piskorski agreed that it could be considered an accurate description of Zmiana.[5]
According to its ideological declaration, Zmiana is a “democratic, anti-capitalist, patriotic, internationalist, peaceful, and progressive force” which “represents the interests of working people, the unemployed, the youth, and the elderly and pensioners” in liberating Poland from the “domination of the structures of big capital and the imperialist powers” and opposing the ruling “party of the Third World War.”[22] Referencing its name, the party seeks “change, not mere cosmetic surgery, but a deep uprooting of the disgraced structures of the anti-social system”. The main demands of the party include:
- exit of Poland from NATO;
- nationalization and socialization of strategic sectors of the Polish economy;
- establishment of a welfare state;
- reindustrialization;
- protection of Polish agriculture;
- reconciliation and deeper ties with "the countries resisting American hegemony", such as Russia and China;
- refuting the "Russophobic, anti-communist" negative assessments of the Polish People’s Republic in Polish media and education.[22]
The party holds a positive views of socialist Poland, writing: "Since the collapse of the Polish People’s Republic in 1989, Poland’s institutions and society have been molded along the lines of neo-liberal capitalism; hence, Poland has become firmly situated in the Western geopolitical camp by dint of military occupation, economic enslavement, and ideological indoctrination." Zmiana argues for an establishment of a 'multipolar' world, arguing that the dominance of USA and Western Europe should be replaced by a "friendship and alliance from the Atlantic to Vladivostok". Greanville Post described the party as a "common anti-imperialist, socially-oriented front."[22]
Zmiana supports Russia in the Russo-Ukrainian War. On Ukraine, the party wrote: "Ukraine is a failed state. As soon as the West, including Poland, supported Bandera's followers in Ukraine, the country plunged into chaos", and "the people of Crimea have had pro-Russian views for a long time. They are afraid of Bandera's followers. We should be afraid too."[16] Zmiana is also supportive of the fallen presidents Bashar al-Assad of Syrian and Muammar Gaddafi of Libya.[29]
Zmiana argues that Poland has become "a kind of transmission belt for Washington's interests", growing so politically and economically dependent on USA that Poland is "ready to commit any stupidity at Uncle Sam's request". The party opposes Polish membership in NATO, believing that it creates dependence on the arms production of Western countries, and has dragged Poland into wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Zmiana also argues that NATO is pushing Poland into a conflict with Russian Federation, and warns of the possibility of 'second Western Betrayal' where the main NATO countries would not defend Poland. The party is staunchly opposed to the presence of American troops in Poland, with its activists stating that "we say no to the presence of American troops in Poland, just as we say no to the presence of all foreign troops in Poland", and that "a nation that does not have the exclusive right to station its own army in its own country is not really an independent nation and is not capable of conducting its own policy".[35]
The party has been described as anti-establishment, and contains far-left, national-conservative and left-nationalist tendencies. Zmiana calls itself "the first non-American party in Poland", and emphasizes its anti-liberalism and anti-capitalism. Polish political scientist Paweł Gotowiecki describes the party as "Polish Syriza", while also noting the pro-Russian views of the party as well as heavy inspiration from Dugin and his Eurasian movement. Zmiana's postulates are also comparable to that of Samoobrona, a party that Piskorski previously belonged to that Gotowiecki classifies as "populist-leftist, agrarian-populist, populist-nationalist, radically populist, popular-nationalist, or belonging to the national left." Gotowiecki also rejects the allegiations that Zmiana was organized by Russian authorities, noting that the party remains too marginal to be influential in politics.[36]
Electoral history
Senate
Election | # of votes |
% of votes |
# of overall seats won |
Government |
---|---|---|---|---|
2023 | 7,958 | 0.51 (#8)[b] | 0 / 460
|
Extra-parliamentary |
On the electoral lists of Przywrócić Prawo . |
References
- ^ a b c d White, Diana Petrova (2017). "The Impact of Geography and Ethnicity on EU Enlargement: New Evidence from the Accession of Eastern Europe". Political Science Dissertations. Georgia State University: 166. doi:10.57709/10110209.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Baziur, Grzegorz (2016). "„Po katastrofie smoleńskiej": polsko-rosyjska wojna informacyjna a geopolityka Federacji Rosyjskiej wobec Polski w latach 2010-2015" (PDF). Przegląd Geopolityczny. 15 (1): 148–152. ISSN 2392-067X.
- ^ a b Wenerski, Łukasz; Kacewicz, Michał (2017). Lóránt Győri (ed.). "Russian soft power in Poland - The Kremlin and pro-Russian organizations" (PDF). Political Capital. Budapest: 27.
- ^ a b Kucharczyk, Jacek; Fuksiewicz, Aleksander (2015). Jacek Kucharczyk; Grigorij Mesežnikov (eds.). "The long shadow of the Kremlin: Polish domestic reactions to the Russian-Ukrainian conflict" (PDF). Diverging Voices, Converging Policies: The Visegrad States’ Reactions to the Russia-Ukraine Conflict. Warsaw: Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung. ISBN 978-80-906270-2-4.
- ^ a b c Herman, Jan (30 May 2019). "Obrona przez ciężką pracę społeczną". Salon24 (in Polish).
W założonej przezeń partii Zmiana starał się połączyć pierwiastek socjalistyczny z pierwiastkiem patriotycznym. To czyniło go „podejrzanym" zarówno dla radykalnych patriotów, jak też dla równie radykalnych socjalistów. Zapytałem go w areszcie wprost: czy wolno mi nazywać ciebie socjalistą-patriotą. Mateusz potwierdził. Nazywałem go zatem patriotą-socjalistą za jego zgodą.
[In his party, Zmiana, he tried to combine socialism and patriotism. This made him ‘suspect’ to both radical patriots and equally radical socialists. I asked him directly in custody: Am I allowed to call you a socialist patriot? Mateusz confirmed. So I called him a socialist patriot with his consent.] - ^ a b c d e f Hylén, Linnea (4 June 2021). ""Dark, Dirty and Secret": A Qualitative Study on Russia's Financial Active Measures" (PDF). Eurasian Studies. Institute for Russian and Eurasian Studies (IRES): 36.
In 2015 he founded the left-wing, populist, pacifist, pro-Kremlin and anti-capitalist party Zmiana (translates to "Change").
- ^ "The Buzz Around The Ballot" (PDF). Visegrad Insight. 2017-12-07. ISSN 2084-8250. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ a b "Zmiana". Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ a b c "Disinformation and the Resilience of Democratic Societies" (PDF). The Polish Institute of International Affairs (Polish: Polski Instytut Spraw Międzynarodowych). Retrieved 2025-02-11.
The exception is Mateusz Piskorski, a pro-Russian political figure who does not have widespread support. In 2015, he founded the pro-Russian leftist party called Zmiana (Change). His comments were widely spread in Sputnik and RT as a "geopolitical expert". In May 2016, Piskorski was arrested by the authorities on charges of espionage for Russia and China, and he was imprisoned. At the same time, his European Centre for Geopolitical Analysis (ECAG) was largely using money from Russia.
- ^ a b "The Buzz Around The Ballot" (PDF). Visegrad Insight: 12. 2017-12-07. ISSN 2084-8250. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
In 2015, the politician founded Poland's first and only openly and blatantly pro-Russian leftist party called Zmiana (Change).
- ^ a b c d White, Diana Petrova (2017). "The Impact of Geography and Ethnicity on EU Enlargement: New Evidence from the Accession of Eastern Europe". Political Science Dissertations. Georgia State University: 166. doi:10.57709/10110209.
The party Zmiana (Polish: Change) was formed in April 2012 by Mateusz Piskorski. The party holds left-wing anti-capitalist views and maintains a close relationship with representatives of the newly-proclaimed Donbas Republic.
- ^ a b Krekó, Péter (2020). "The Drivers of Disinformation in Central and Eastern Europe and Their Utilization During the Pandemic" (PDF). GlobSec Policy Brief. IWM/Erste Stiftung: 6.
According to Polish counterintelligence, Mateusz Piskorski, the leader of the Polish leftist party Change (Zmiana), as well as former activists of the far-right Polish Congress of the New Right (KNP) did espionage on the behalf of Russia, and the latter seemed to participate in "active measures" on Ukrainian territory in 2014 to provoke an ethnic conflict against Polish minorities in western Ukraine.
- ^ [6][9][10][11][12]
- ^ Krekó, Péter; Győri, Lóránt; Zgut, Edit (2017). Pozdrowienia z Rosji: Działalność prorosyjskich ekstremistycznych grup szerzących nienawiść w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej (PDF). Political Capital. p. 14. ISBN 978-963-9607-14-9.
Polski kontrwywiad prowadzi obecnie dochodzenie w sprawie Mateusza Piskorskiego, przywódcy polskiej skrajnie lewicowej partii Zmiana, a także dawnych działaczy skrajnie prawicowego Kongresu Nowej Prawicy (KNP), w związku z zarzutami o szpiegostwo na rzecz Rosji.
[Polish counterintelligence is currently investigating Mateusz Piskorski, the leader of the Polish far-left party Zmiana, as well as former activists of the far-right New Right Congress (KNP), in connection with allegations of spying for Russia.] - ^ a b "Trzecia partia prorosyjska w Polsce? Wpływy Kremla rosną, #lexTusk temu nie przeszkadza". 2023-07-28. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
Kiedy kilkanaście lat temu Mateusz Piskorski zakładał prorosyjską partię „Zmiana", nie udało mu się doprowadzić do jej rejestracji, zaś on sam po pewnym czasie został aresztowany pod zarzutami szpiegostwa na rzecz Rosji (proces do dziś się nie zakończył).
[When a few years ago Mateusz Piskorski established the pro-Russian party "Zmiana", he didn't manage to register it, and he himself was arrested under the accusation of espionage for Russia (legal process did not conclude to this day).] - ^ a b Krekó, Péter; Győri, Lóránt; Zgut, Edit (2017). Pozdrowienia z Rosji: Działalność prorosyjskich ekstremistycznych grup szerzących nienawiść w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej (PDF). Political Capital. p. 45. ISBN 978-963-9607-14-9.
- ^ a b c d Groszewska, Ewa (2017). "The new Polish government: Anti-neoliberal but anti-left profile first" (PDF). Revolutionary Marxism: 41.
- ^ a b Rekawek, Kacper; Renard, Thomas; Molas, Bàrbara (2024). Russia and the Far-Right: Insights from Ten European Countries (PDF). The Hague: International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) Press. p. 138. doi:10.19165/2024.1563. ISBN 9789083419916. ISSN 2468-0486.
- ^ Rekawek, Kacper; Renard, Thomas; Molas, Bàrbara (2024). Russia and the Far-Right: Insights from Ten European Countries (PDF). The Hague: International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) Press. p. 314. doi:10.19165/2024.1563. ISBN 9789083419916. ISSN 2468-0486.
- ^ a b Wałdoch, Marcin (2021). Kamila Sierzputowska; Sławomir Sadowski; Albert Kotowski; Krzysztof Garczewski (eds.). "Idee antynatowskie w nurtach polskiej myśli politycznej XXI wieku". in: Wielowektorowość polskiej polityki bezpieczeństwa w XXI wieku. Wybrane aspekty. Bydgoszcz: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Kazimierza Wielkiego: 112.
... ludowo-narodowe i panslawistyczne (Przymierze Ludowo-Narodowe, Związek Słowiański, antykapitalistyczna i wyraźnie prorosyjska Partia Zmiana – dotąd niezarejestrowana przez sąd),
[... national-popular and pan-Slavic (National-Popular Alliance, Slavic Union, anti-capitalist and clearly pro-Russian Party Zmiana – not yet registered by the court),] - ^ [6][11][20]
- ^ a b c d e Arnoldski, J. (15 June 2015). "The Birth of Zmiana and the Syncretic Struggle in Poland". Greanville Post. Center for Syncretic Studies.
- ^ "Partia Zmiana planowała szczyt anty-NATO?". 2016-06-03. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ a b Hylén, Linnea (4 June 2021). ""Dark, Dirty and Secret": A Qualitative Study on Russia's Financial Active Measures" (PDF). Eurasian Studies. Institute for Russian and Eurasian Studies (IRES): 35–36.
- ^ Lebourg, Nicolas (2018). "The French Far Right in Russia's Orbit" (PDF). Research Report. New York: Carnegie Council: 21.
- ^ Rekawek, Kacper; Renard, Thomas; Molas, Bàrbara (2024). Russia and the Far-Right: Insights from Ten European Countries (PDF). The Hague: International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) Press. p. 57. doi:10.19165/2024.1563. ISBN 9789083419916. ISSN 2468-0486.
- ^ Pacula, Paulina (23 March 2015). "New pro-Russia party emerges in Poland". EUobserver. Warsaw.
- ^ Kucharczyk, Jacek (2017). "Exploiting Political Polarization in Poland" (PDF). Sharp Power: Rising Authoritarian Influence. National Endowment for Democracy: 106–108.
- ^ a b Neumann, Jakub (13 November 2019). "Die Falanga in Polen: Gekaufter „Terror"?" (in German).
- ^ "Poland's pro-Russia Zmiana party urges embrace of Putin". 2015-03-16. Archived from the original on 2015-03-16. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ a b "Kulisy zatrzymania Mateusza Piskorskiego z prorosyjskiej partii Zmiana. W Polsce miał się odbyć szczyt anty-NATO". 2016-06-03. Archived from the original on 2025-02-11. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ "Oskarżony o szpiegostwo Mateusz Piskorski wychodzi z aresztu". Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ "Wyniki wyborów 2019 do Senatu RP". Retrieved 2025-02-11.
- ^ "What's Left of the Soviet Union" (PDF). Warsaw East European Review. 2017. Retrieved 2025-02-11.
Perhaps the most visible pro-Putin supporter in public life is Mateusz Piskorski, even more so since he became one of the leading organisers of the political party Zmiana (Change). Piskorski, associated with Polskie Towarzystwo Geopolityczne, acts as Polish political scientist and international observer in "missions" to Moscow-annexed Crimea. He travelled to Syria several times, supporting Assad's regime. Zmiana advocates a total overhaul of the political system in Poland and for Poland's withdrawal from NATO.
- ^ Wałdoch, Marcin (2021). Kamila Sierzputowska; Sławomir Sadowski; Albert Kotowski; Krzysztof Garczewski (eds.). "Idee antynatowskie w nurtach polskiej myśli politycznej XXI wieku". in: Wielowektorowość polskiej polityki bezpieczeństwa w XXI wieku. Wybrane aspekty. Bydgoszcz: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Kazimierza Wielkiego: 114.
- ^ Gotowiecki, Paweł (2016). ""Partia rosyjska" w Polsce – między mitem a rzeczywistością" (PDF). Kryzys ukraiński i jego znaczenie dla bezpieczeństwa międzynarodowego: aspekty polityczno-militarne (in Polish). 6 (1). Ostrowiec Świętokrzyski: Ante Portas: Studia nad Bezpieczeństwem: 102–104. ISSN 2353-6306.
Notes
- ^ Zmiana officially has never been registered as a political party because it was refused a registration by a court.[3]
- ^ Percentage of votes for electoral list Przywrócić Prawo
You must be logged in to post a comment.