William Ryan (psychologist)

William Ryan
Born(1923-09-20)September 20, 1923
DiedJune 7, 2002(2002-06-07) (aged 78)
Boston, Massachusetts
Known forIdea of "Victim blaming"
Spouse
​
(m. 1951)​
Children1; Elizabeth
Academic background
EducationBoston University
Academic work
DisciplinePsychologist
InstitutionsBoston College
Notable worksBlaming the Victim (1971)

William J. Ryan Jr. (September 20, 1923 – June 7, 2002) was a psychologist, author, and civil rights activist. He is best known for his exposure of the sociological phenomenon of "blaming the victim", which he articulated in his 1971 book of the same name. Ryan's work is considered a major structuralist rebuttal to the Moynihan Report.[1] The 1965 report had mainly attributed the high poverty rate among African Americans to a "tangle of pathology" in Negro families,[2] such as a preponderance of out-of-wedlock births, absent fathers, and single-mother households. Ryan rejected this explanation of supposed cultural deprivation for its confusion of cause and effect, a fallacy he termed "victim blaming".[3][4]

Early life

Ryan was born in Everett, Massachusetts on September 20, 1923, into a Catholic family of Democrats,[5] the only child[6] of William J. Ryan and Marion C. Ryan (née Evans).[7] He joined the U.S. Army Air Corps during World War II. He was a non-combatant, working as a cryptographer in the Caribbean, "doing coding and decoding".[5] Upon leaving military service at age 25, he enrolled at Boston University.[8] As an undergraduate, he grew interested in psychology and earned a degree in that field. He later obtained staff positions in the Boston Psychopathic Hospital, the South Shore Guidance Center, and the Mount Auburn Hospital.[9]

In 1951, Ryan married Phyllis Milgroom (Phyllis M. Ryan), the daughter of Russian immigrants and a practicing Jew from a large Jewish family. A graduate of Boston's Northeastern University, she worked as a psychiatric social worker in the local state mental health system. During their marriage, Ryan converted to Judaism. According to his wife's aunt, Anne A. Jackson, Ryan learned Hebrew,[10] spoke Yiddish,[11] and studied Jewish scholarship. Jackson recalled a special Haggadah he wrote for the Passover service that was used by all synagogue members:[10] "[H]e mentioned every kind of worthwhile consideration. I think he even had gays in there. And, of course, he had the Blacks and the inequalities that we've had in this country."[12][13]

Career

Ryan undertook his graduate work at Boston University, where he obtained a Ph.D. in 1958 in clinical psychology.[8] However, he found himself increasingly interested in social and community psychology as he became engaged by societal issues and matters of equality.[14] Starting in the late 1950s, he joined his wife in a long commitment to the civil rights movement. They were activists in the Boston area for fair housing and educational equity.[15] They also advocated for welfare rights and prison reform.[16] In 1973, he helped organize the Citizen Observer program in Walpole State Prison.[17]

By 1965, Ryan was serving as a faculty member in the Harvard Medical School Laboratory of Community Psychiatry.[18] In 1969, he was hired by Boston College, where he held the position of Professor of Psychology for 25 years.[19]

Soon after Daniel Patrick Moynihan's 1965 report, The Negro Family: The Case for National Action, was made public, Ryan voiced his opposition. In a November 1965 article in The Nation, he wrote that the Moynihan Report "seduces the reader into believing that it is not racism and discrimination but the weaknesses and defects of the Negro himself that account for the present status of inequality between Negro and white."[20] Ryan subsequently targeted other studies such as the 1966 Coleman Report,[21] which he regarded as further instances of attributing societal inequality to character flaws.[22]

In the 1969 anthology Distress in the City, edited by Ryan, he contributed several essays including "Fretting About the Poor".[23] In it he generalized his critique of recent sociological studies into a broader concept he called "blaming the victim", which he described as "an intellectual process whereby a social problem is analyzed in such a way that the causation is found to be in the qualities and characteristics of the victim rather than in any deficiencies or structural defects in his environment."[24] In 1971, he expanded the concept into book-length form in Blaming the Victim:

To illustrate his theory, Dr. Ryan once pointed to a coloring book that was critical of a mother who did not constantly watch her infant to make sure the child did not eat lead paint chips. "No one would argue against the idea that it is important to spread knowledge about the danger of eating lead paint," he said. But the blame, he added, lay with whoever left poisonous paint on apartment walls.[8][25]

The book became "one of the all-time academic best sellers",[8] and was followed in 1976 with a revised, mass-market paperback edition.

In 1981, Ryan published his final book, Equality, which explored notions of individualism, fair play and equal opportunity, and analyzed how inequality comes about. He defined two schools of thought in the debate about equality and inequality. One school of thought was Fair Play: a person's right to pursue happiness with minimal interference. Ryan argued that the proponents of this school believed in equality of opportunity, and felt that inequality arises in society because of differences in the internal characteristics of individuals.[26][27] The other school of thought was Fair Share: a person's right to "a reasonable share of society's resources sufficient to sustain life at a decent standard of humanity."[28] Ryan asserted that the proponents of this school (of which he was one) believed that inequality is a preexisting state which stems primarily from external factors. He wrote: "Equality of opportunity is, inevitably, a pathway to inequality, and Fair Play is not a rule for achieving equality, but rather an excuse for inequality."[29] He dedicated the book to his wife Phyllis and thanked their daughter Elizabeth in the Acknowledgments for having provided him with "a brilliant analysis of early draft material" that helped him "immeasurably in rethinking and reorganizing [his] work".[30]

The American Psychological Association presented Ryan with its 1993 Society for Community Research and Action Award for his distinguished contributions to theory and research in community psychology.[31] However, by the last decade of his life, Ryan had misgivings about psychology. In 1996, he concluded that "psychology has become the science of understanding internal individual differences, which leads to kinds of ideological distortions that support inequality."[32]

On June 7, 2002, Ryan died in a Boston hospital. He was 78.[7][8]

Publications

Articles

  • With Saul Cooper and Bellenden R. Hutcheson. Ryan, William (1959). "Classroom screening for emotional disturbance". American Psychologist. 14: 341.
  • Ryan, William (1965a). "Savage discovery: The Moynihan Report" (PDF). The Nation. 201 (22 November): 380–384. Retrieved 29 October 2025.
  • —— (1965b). "The new genteel racism". The Crisis. 72 (10): 623–631, 644.
  • —— (1966). "Citizens in mental health--what are they for?". Mental Hygiene. 50 (4): 597–600. An extract entitled "Citizen" and Mental Health' is available at Rehabilitation Record. 1967. 8 (March–April): 6. Accessed 8 December 2024.
  • Ryan, William; et al. (1967). "Feedback from our readers". Trans-action. 4 (3): 62–64. doi:10.1007/BF03180043. Retrieved 6 December 2024.
  • Ryan, William (1969). "Community care in historical perspective: Implications for mental health services and professionals". Canada's Mental Health. Supplement (60): March–April.
  • —— (1971b). "Blaming the victim: The folklore of cultural deprivation". This Magazine is About Schools. 5 (Spring) (2): 97–117. (See Connexions. Accessed 8 December 2024.)
  • —— (1971c). "Emotional disorder as a social problem: Implications for mental health programs". American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 41 (4): 638–645. doi:10.1111/j.1939-0025.1971.tb03224.x. PMID 5558616. Reprinted in Denner, Bruce; Price, Richard H., eds. (1973). Community Mental Health Social Action and Inaction. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Windton. pp. 22–30. ISBN 0-03-085651-5. Retrieved 8 December 2024.
  • —— (1971d). "Unsocialized medicine". Contemporary Psychology. XVI (4): 256–258. doi:10.1037/014050.
  • —— (1994). "Many cooks, brave men, apples, and oranges: How people think about equality". American Journal of Community Psychology. 22 (1): 25–35. doi:10.1007/BF02506815.

Chapters

  • Ryan, William (1967). "Preventive Services in the Social Context: Power, Pathology, and Prevention". In Bloom, Bernard L.; Buck, Dorothy P. (eds.). Preventive Services in Mental Health Programs: Proceedings of the Mental Health Institute at Salt Lake City, Utah, May 31- June 2, 1967. Boulder, Colorado: Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education.
  • —— (1969b). "A New Mental Health Agenda". In Ryan, William (ed.). Distress in the City: Essays on the Design and Administration of Urban Mental Health Services. Cleveland, Ohio: The Press of Case Western Reserve University. ISBN 978-0829501490. Retrieved 10 December 2024.
  • —— (1969c). "Distress in the City: A Summary Report of the Boston Mental Health Survey". In Ryan, William (ed.). Distress in the City: Essays on the Design and Administration of Urban Mental Health Services. Cleveland, Ohio: The Press of Case Western Reserve University. ISBN 978-0829501490. Retrieved 10 December 2024.
  • —— (1969d). "Fretting About the Poor". In Ryan, William (ed.). Distress in the City: Essays on the Design and Administration of Urban Mental Health Services. Cleveland, Ohio: The Press of Case Western Reserve University. pp. 262–67. ISBN 978-0829501490. Retrieved 10 December 2024.
  • —— (1971e). "The Social Welfare Client: Blaming the Victim". In Kalz, A. J. (ed.). The Social Welfare Forum 1971 Official Proceedings, 98th Annual Forum, National Conference on Social Welfare, Dallas, Texas, May 16-May 21, 1971. New York: Columbia University Press.

Monographs

  • Ryan, William; Morris, Laura B. (1967). Child welfare problems and potentials: A study of intake of child welfare agencies in metropolitan Boston. Monograph III. Boston, Massachusetts: Massachusetts Committee on Children and Youth.
  • With Ali Banuazizi. Ryan, William (1972). Mental health planning in metropolitan areas. Community Psychology Monograph No. 1. Boston: Boston College.
  • With Allan Sloan, Mania Seferi and Elaine Werby. Ryan, William (1974). All in together: An evaluation of mixed-income multi-family housing. Boston: Massachusetts Housing Finance Agency.

Books

Notes

  1. ^ Sanneh, Kelefa (9 February 2015). "Don't Be Like That". The New Yorker. Retrieved 9 April 2017.
  2. ^ Moynihan wrote: 'most Negro youth are in danger of being caught up in the tangle of pathology that affects their world, and probably a majority are so entrapped.' (Moynihan 1965, p. 30) (Italics in the original) Also he claimed: 'At the heart of the deterioration of the fabric of Negro society is the deterioration of the Negro family. (Moynihan 1965, p. 5)
  3. ^ Lykes 1996a, p. 351.
  4. ^ Miller, Jim Wayne (1978). "Appalachian Values/American Values: Part III". Appalachian Heritage. 6 (2). The University of North Carolina Press – via Project Muse. Appalachian writer Jim Wayne Miller analyzed the fallacy as a three-step process: "First, identify a social problem. Second, study those affected by the problem and discover in what ways they are different from the rest of us as a consequence of deprivation and injustice. Third, define the difference as the cause of the social problem itself."
  5. ^ a b Lykes 1996a, p. 353.
  6. ^ Jackson 2000, p. 10.
  7. ^ a b Long, Tom (11 June 2002). "William J. Ryan; Fought Bias Against the Poor, 78". Boston Globe.
  8. ^ a b c d e "William J. Ryan, 78, Sociologist; Explored the Blaming of Victims". The New York Times. 13 June 2002. Retrieved 9 April 2017.
  9. ^ "Contributors to This Issue". Psychiatric Quarterly Supplement. 37–38: 384. 1963.
  10. ^ a b Jackson 1997, p. 1.
  11. ^ Jackson 1997, p. 40.
  12. ^ Jackson 2000, p. 17.
  13. ^ Ryan also devoted a preliminary page of his 1981 book Equality to one of the famous sayings of Pirkei Avot that Rabbi Tarfon, the Jewish scholar, cited: 'Rabbi Tarfon used to say: You are not required to complete the task; but neither are you free to desist from it. – Pirke Avoth (Sayings of the Fathers).'
  14. ^ Lykes 1996a, p. 354.
  15. ^ Geismer, Lily D. (2010). Don't Blame Us: Grassroots Liberalism in Massachusetts, 1960-1990 (PDF) (Thesis). University of Michigan. Archived from the original (PDF) on 24 October 2014.
  16. ^ Roberts, Paige (October 2003). "Finding Aid for Phyllis M. Ryan Papers". Northeastern University Archives and Special Collection. Archived from the original on October 24, 2014.
  17. ^ Ryan 1981, p. 258.
  18. ^ Broskowski & Khajavi 1973.
  19. ^ Steele 1994.
  20. ^ Ryan 1965a.
  21. ^ Ryan 1976, pp. 44–54.
  22. ^ Ryan 1976, pp. 5–7.
  23. ^ Ryan 1969a.
  24. ^ Ryan 1969d, pp. 262–263.
  25. ^ Ryan 1976, p. 23.
  26. ^ Ryan 1981, pp. 64–65.
  27. ^ Krause 1987.
  28. ^ Ryan 1981, p. 9.
  29. ^ Ryan 1981, p. 36.
  30. ^ Ryan 1981, p. xiii.
  31. ^ Albee 1994b.
  32. ^ Lykes 1996a, p. 366.

References

Further reading

allikas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Ryan_(psychologist)